Saturday, August 25, 2007

2007 A-U pre-view: The Cons

This post is the third in a series. In the event you're looking for the next Cheese Puff Preview, the remaining editions have been moved to in-season. Best laid plans ganging oft agley and all. Sorry.



After hitting the Pros last time out, it's time to count down the Cons side of the argument for 2007 Auburn.

10. The blocking of Tommy "Not a Blocking Tight End" Trott. I think every fan has at least one player on their Favorite Team that they like, sure, I mean, they play for my Favorite Team but ... said fan would also like said player to be a just a bit better at playing football. We're not talking about the Chris Cappses of the world here. We're talking about the guys who aren't really bad ... they're just not as good as we'd like. And when Tommy Trott waved the ball around like a semaphore flag before having it predictably knocked loose inside the Florida 5 last year, he became that guy at the JCCW. He then didn't do much to lose said designation down the stretch as a disproportionate number of the many "Kenny Irons takes the handoff, looks for some room on the right, but there's nothing there and he's tackled for a loss of a yard" plays could be laid at his feet. Sorry, Tommy. But given the, ahem, inexperience along the rest of the line, I'm not sure Auburn can afford to play a TE that can't stick with his blocks.

Counter: Trott is a valuable receiver, and with Bennett and McKenzie both available, he doesn't have to be an every-down player any more. Trott can rotate in when receivers are needed and rotate out when power blocking is needed ... provided he doesn't do it so often it becomes a tip-off.

9. Carl Stewart's new trick hamstring. When I wrote that I didn't want Stewart to come back until 30 minutes before the K-St. kickoff, I was joking. Mostly. But it's looking like Stewart won't be back too much before then, if at all. He hasn't practiced a day this fall and still only "hopes to be full speed by early next week." This is precisely the sort of injury that hangs around like a stale fart (Sorry ...forgot Simmons has that charming phrase copyrighted) all season and even if Stewart does manage to get fully recovered, there's no way he's as in synch as he should be after missing virtually every minute of camp. And (I'll say it again) Cox is the only player the Auburn offense would have more trouble replacing other than Stewart.

Counter: The missed time won't really hurt a player as savvy and experienced as Stewart past maybe the first couple of weeks--and as difficult as those games might be, they're not going to Gainesville or Baton Rouge, either. Auburn's coaches know that, too. Maybe that's given them the incentive to be unusually cautious with an injury that's not as serious as the missed time might indicate?

8. The mortal terror of a potential injury to Cox. That's an obtuse way (the only way we know here, you'll notice) of saying the backup QB situation is still more heart-stopping than the Exorcist. It's terrific that Blake Field has convinced Phillip Marshall the Auburn offense wouldn't become a complete train wreck if he ended up under center ... but geez, I'll believe it when I see it. (Ironically, I desperately hope Cox stays healthy and we never see it. So Blake Field, one of my biggest wishes for Auburn this year is that I doubt you 'til the end. Apologies.) Caudle, of course, is an injury casualty for the forseeable future. Burns might be AU's best bet if Cox goes down, but to have to burn his redshirt the same year we've got a third-year senior starter would be the biggest waste since the Superconducting Suprcollider. And I'm far from convinced even Burns would be a match for most SEC teams.

Counter: Hey, knock on wood, Cox has been plenty durable so far. If he does stay healthy, we could have Canadian alt-country chanteuse Neko Case for a backup QB and it wouldn't matter. In fact, it might be a good idea.

If you'd listened to "The Tigers Have Spoken," you'd have a crush, too.

7. Perpeutual Tubbidity. The big bright green hype machine is spitting out names other than Auburn's these days, but if the undefeated Tigers take down an undefeated Gator squad in Gainesville? If they somehow survive Baton Rouge, even if there's a loss along the way there? Here come the "best team in the SEC whispers" and the talk about a Florida-like run ... and then that Tubby thing happens and everything comes to a crashing halt. 2004 obviously excepted, Auburn's been so allergic to prosperity in recent years I think it might be worth asking the team doctor if Allegra is right for the team.

Counter: Uh, Auburn'll cross this bridge when it gets there. Tubbidity means that, yes, an undefeated season is about as likely as Hillary Clinton getting an invitation to an Ann Coulter dinner party. But it's already about that likely ... or less.

Things get a lot more serious from here, by the way.

6. Rod Smith, No. 1 receiver. Prechae Rodriguez, No. 2 receiver. Nameless Faceless, No. 3 receiver. All right, so the real No. 3 receiver is probably Robert Dunn, or maybe James Swinton or Tim Hawthorne or Chris Slaughter or Montez Billings ... but geez, this year at least, none of these guys (Smith and Rodriguez included) is exactly going to be Terry Beasley. They're not likely to even be Devin Aromashadu or Willie Gosha. Rod Smith is a solid possession guy, but I feel fairly certain Bo Pelini isn't lying awake at 3 a.m. trying to figure out how to contain him, or any of AU's receivers. On paper, this the weakest corps of wideouts of Tubby's tenure.

Counter: It might be true that there's not much difference between Auburn's No. 1 guy and No. 8 guy, but the madding crowd at this position means that the odds are in Auburn's favor that someone is going to end up being a lot better than we expect. Ronney Daniels came out of nowhere. Courtney Taylor was a solid contributor as a freshman. There's too many recruiting stars piled up on that list of names for someone not to break out. (Hawthorne and your swollen recruiting rep, I'm looking at you. Injuries, I know, but I heard more about you last year than I have at any point this fall. What's up?)

5. The Freshman Invastion. When copy editors are writing headlines about your team like "Nine freshmen may play key roles at your team" and your team doesn't play in the Sun Belt, that's not a good thing. Supremely talented as guys like Ziemba, McNeil, and Bo Harris might be, you generally need more than pure talent to survive against the likes of, say, Glenn Dorsey. As noted previously, this is a particular problem for the linebackers. As currently constructed the Auburn defense is an invulnerable fire-breathing death-beast. But should a couple of injuries (Johnson) and/or suspensions (Blackmon) strike, the linebackers are going to the blinking red light on a Dr. Wily invention that screams "weak spot."

Counter: It's not like freshmen, true or otherwise, succeeding in the SEC is unheard of. At Auburn alone since the turn of the century, you've got the aforementioned Courtney Taylor. DeMarco McNeil. Cadillac. SenDerrick Marks just last year. All terrific players, but did any of them arrive with so much more guru respect than Ziemba or McNeil? (Well, maybe Cadillac.) It would be nice, yes, if we had a senior Ziemba to keep freshman Ziemba off the field. But either Ziemba (particularly given that Nall seems so high on him) is probably going to be succeed. And even at linebacker, last year Craig Stevens was able to crack the rotation as a true frosh, and Auburn's world did somehow continue to spin.

4. Then again, it ain't just Ziemba along the offensive line. Redshirt frosh Mike Berry's now the starting right guard. Tyronne Green's a first-time starter at left guard. Jason Bosley only started a handful of games in 2006 and didn't set the world on fire. Ziemba means Auburn will start a freshman at both positions on the right side. The two-deep likely includes yet another true frosh in center Ryan Pugh as well as redshirt freshman Byron Isom. The one guy Auburn fans were definitely counting on to help out King Dunlap, one-time mega-recruit Leon Hart, has continued his underwhelming career by hurting his ankle and watching the unheralded Berry steal his spot.

The bottom line: as far as sure things in 2007 along Auburn's offensive line go, it's Dunlap and no one else.

Counter: Seriously: whatever. Last year's line was supposed to be oh-so-dominant, with seniors like Grubbs and Palmer and Duckworth and Cope around. It never was. Neither was the 2003 line that was going to pave to way to Cadillac and Brown's co-Heismans. Auburn's best lines under Tubby? Like his teams as a whole, the one we haven't seen coming: 2000. 2002. 2004. 2007? I know this: when last year's starters had as much experience as they had and they played as inconsistently as Auburn's did last season, it's better not having returning starters than it is having them. Experience or not, returning starters or not, there's too much talent here for Hugh Nall to let the problems that happened last year happen again. Scary as things are on paper, the JCCW's guess is that by season's end, Auburn's issues here will look greatly, greatly exaggerated.

3. Inevitable regression to the mean. I made a mental note ahead of my my look at Phil Steele's forecasts of doom based on Auburn's low yardage efficiency and repeated success in close games in 2006 that SMQ was a 100 percent guaranteed lock to echo those sentiments in the SEC edition of "Life on the Margins." I brain-locked and forgot to include the note, but sure enough, there it was this week, in handy chart form. Auburn was a very fortunate team last year and to rely on that fortune again isn't just tempting fate, it's having a few drinks with fate after work, asking fate back to your apartment afterward, and leaving fate on your couch while you "slip into something more comfortable." (Fate's going to have a hard time saying no, is what I'm saying.)

Counter: The linked post above mostly covers it. But it might be worth noting that Auburn is 22-6 since 2001 and 13-2 since 2003 in one-possession games (and the 2006 Florida game, which was in disguise). Auburn hasn't finished worse than .500 in those games since 1998, when it went 1-2. I wouldn't usually dare challenge the widely-held and sound statistical notion that there's no such thing as "clutch," that chance really does even out over time ... but that sure as hell looks like a trend, doesn't it?

2. (Un-?) Special teams. A true freshman placekicker. A redshirt freshman punter. The kickoff returner gone with a broken toe for the first several weeks. The punt returner barely hanging onto his job. If these units are as weak as they look on paper and Auburn gets back into the slugfests of 2006 where special teams will make the difference in the game, Auburn will be in Lake Baikal-deep trouble.


A song about what Auburn will be in if Byrum and Shoemaker don't come through.

Counter: For starters, Byrum and Shoemaker haven't sucked in practice. Not even a little bit. God only knows if it'll translate this Saturday, but there's hope. Additionally, when it comes to placekicking, Florida could have had a trained mule handling kicks last year and not done any worse, and it hurt them so badly they only beat Ohio St. by 27 in the national title game. As for the returns, well, Davis'll be back eventually and it's not like punt returning has been a strength since Cadillac left.

1. A schedule that hates you, and hates your children. The consensus SEC champ and No. 2 team in the country. The defending national champions featuring the offense their coach has always dreamed of building. The defending SEC West champs, Auburn's single biggest bogey team and home to the country's single best player. And the team that last November handed the Tigers their most emabrrassing loss in years and by nearly all accounts will have only improved. All four of them are on the road.

And that's just the start. There's also two quality BCS non-conference opponents, the second of which has made an annual habit of felling the biggest redwoods on their schedule. There's the traditional doormat who everyone knows is going to upset one of the conference powers and happens to be innocuously snuggled between the Gators and Hogs like a land mine. And there is always the Tide, now coached by an actual coach, and that game's razor's edge of adrenaline and pressure.

It is a schedule that only a sadist, or Idi Amin, or a Tide fan could love.

Counter: There's no real counter here. Sure, Auburn will stand a good shot of surprising the Gators. No one really know what's going to happen with Arkansas and the Tigers will be ready to sacrifice various minor appendages for revenge. LSU is coached by Les Miles and not Jimbo Fisher. And it's not like winning in Athens has ever been an issue. But blowing any of these teams out will be an order taller than tallerson, and that nagging 6-0 close game record last year makes me think that close games will simply not break AU's way this year. Going just 2-2 on this yellow brick cobblestones-made-from-the-bones-of-baby-seals road will be a terrific accomplishment.

Of course, all but the most "National title or bust!" Auburn fans will be happy with 2-2, because the consensus is that the Tigers will sweep their home games. But since 1993, Auburn's finished with an unblemished home record precisely twice, in 2000 and again in 2004. And three (maybe four, though I really think K-St just isn't that big a threat) teams that will visit Jordan-Hare will have more than a fighting chance and grabbing the upset that Tubby's teams have been so vulnerable to over the years.

There are bright sides to many of the arguments brought forth against Auburn's success this season. The team's critics should remember them. But it's true there's no bright side to this schedule.

Thursday, August 23, 2007

2007 A-U pre-view: The Pros

This post is the second in a series. In the event you're looking for the next Cheese Puff Preview, the remaining editions have been moved to in-season. Best laid plans ganging oft agley and all. Sorry.



I doubt I'll ever be much interested in writing the traditional "Auburn is set at seventh-string tight end, where walk-on Forrest McWilliker has proven himself more than capable of walking and chewing gum at the same time" exahustive positional breakdown. Or even a more casual unit-by-unit thing. There's a bajillion magazines and half a bajillion websites out there that have already done the same thing, and I can't imagine anyone who's reading this isn't already well aware by now that, say, Antonio Coleman, Octavius Balkcom, Zach Clayton, etc. give Auburn great depth at defensive end.

I'd rather talk about exactly how pumped up Auburn fans should be about the fact that we have great depth at defensive end, or how worried sick that we have less than great depth at linebacker. So here's a countdown of 10 Pros, the 10 biggest reasons I'm confident about the 2007 season, accompanied by their respective counterpoints for balance's sake. Next post will be the 10 Cons and their counterpoints. By the end, the JCCW will have pretty much covered the things worth covering with the season now a week away, thank everything holy.

So, the Pros, with the quick caveat that I am most certainly the glass-half-full type and these reflect that:

10. The comic off-season hijinks of our nonconference opponents. When I first started really buckling down on my research for this season (i.e. blew my entire weekly Panera-double-mocha-and-a-cream-cheese-bagel-for-every-breakfast allowance on Steele, Street and Smith's, Sporting News, etc.) the 1-2 jab of K-St. and South Florida had me deeply uneasy. Sure, Auburn had finally gotten over that Week 1 hump (and how) against Wazzu last year, but that was just one decent non-league opponent. What happens when there's two back-to-back, with the substantially more dangerous team potentially lying in wait on the back half after an over-confidence generating initial rout?

Well, the first thing that happens is that Team A's quarterback hops on the Phillip Fulmer see-food diet and starts going 0-for-the-whole-practice*, and Team B sees virtually everyone on the completed o-line two-deep pick up some form of nagging injury. No, Auburn's injury situation hasn't exactly been cause to break out the party hats and kazoos, either, but overall I would guess Tubby's still happier with how his two-a-days have gone than either Prince or Leavitt. Consider the JCCW's Terror Alert level been downgraded a color.

Counter: Isn't this exactly how K-St. and USF want Auburn to see them?
Counter-counter: At home and at night, will it matter?

9. A coaching staff that's better than yours. And I'm not even talking about the two guys at the top of the heap. I'm talking about Will Muschamp. Eddie Gran. Hugh Nall. James Willis. Every one of those guys is a proven, bankable commodity. Say what you want about Ensminger, but he's a former OC at La. Tech (when they were worth a damn) and Texas A&M ... and on Auburn's coaching staff this season, he's coaching the tight ends. The stability and continuity here from is also particularly important when you consider that some other teams we're just a bit interested in defeating ain't got it.

Counter: Nall's Midas touch from 2004 and 2005 didn't seem to be entirely in effect last season, did it? And Muschamp's forces weren't exactly prepared week-in and week-out, were they?
Counter-counter: Meaning a) Nall's due for a rebound b) he'll make adjustments in Year Two.

8. Three professional-grade tight ends. Most schools would be happy just to have "Stone-" Cole Bennett, a Jason Witten clone capable of eating defensive linemen for breakfast in the power running game and when Auburn airs it out, nabbing an on-the-go lunch of any linebacker who tries to cover him. But Auburn also has athletic-as-hell Gabe McKenzie and Tommy "Not a Blocking Tight End" Trott, who while not a blocking tight end has the kind of hands that make Borges gush about his potential every time he's brought up. (You know, I should probably change "the kind of hands that make Borges gush" to a less ... peculiar-sounding phrase. Oh well.)

Counter: Bennett may say he's in great shape after the season-ender last year, but is he? And it's not like Borges seemed to go to great lengths to get these guys involved down the 2006 stretch.
Counter-counter: Borges likely would have paid the tight ends substantially more attention if Bennett had been on of him. Also, with McKenzie and Trott around Bennett doesn't have to be an every-down player--just every critical down.

7.King Dunlap. I made this same joke last year, but if your name is friggin' King Dunlap, you are going to be an all-conference caliber offensive lineman if your ancestry is Borneo pygmy on your Mom's side and Tom Cruise on your Dad's. These are the bedrocks great lines are built around.

Counter: Does Auburn really have the materials to build around Dunlap with?
Counter-counter: Either way, it's simply not going to be any worse than last year. Can't be.

6. The Auburn running back tradition upheld. Remember, if you've forgotten: there were times in 2005 when Brad Lester and Kenny Irons were both healthy, and Lester got more carries. Remember than Ben Tate had the team's highest rushing average for a running back last year by more than two full yards, impressive even if he'd been running against Boy Scout troop 673. And of course Borges has more or less gone on record as saying Fannin's got more talent than either. Two years ago Tre Smith had first crack, but we all expected that even if it didn't work out with Smith, someone would emerge to carry the load. I have confidence in Lester. But if not, hey ... someone's going to emerge again.

Counter: Lester injures himself tying his cleats, Tate's a paper Tiger who built his rep against the Sisters of the Poor, and no really knows yet about Fannin.
Counter-counter: Call me crazy, but I think Al Borges would, in fact, know. This is Auburn. We're not going without a competent running back.

5. Quentin Groves. Tray Blackmon. I pray thusly for you, O my enemies in purple, in crimson, in red-and-black and whatever they happen to call that color at Arkansas cardinal: May your death, at the least, come swiftly. For it will not come without pain. To rest in even the most infintesimal flicker of hope that it shall not is to entreat the grandest of self-deceptions, and bitter lies.

Counter: Groves can be run on and you just know Blackmon's still got one foot in the doghouse.
Counter-counter: Straws, the grasping of, etc.

4. Al Borges. 33-5 overall. 22-3 in the SEC. With his unit coming off of a subpar year and detractors everywhere slamming his quarterback, his line, his receivers. This is a man with too much skill and pride to fail in nearly any circumstance; with these circumstances, when that quarterback is a healthy senior in his third year of starting and the blanket dismissal of his receivers ignores the solidity of Bennett, Stewart, and Smith and he has this many weapons to line up behind his quarterback ... he is simply not going to fail us.

Counter: If the line doesn't hold up, all of Cox's experience and the running backs' speed and the tight ends' versatility won't make any difference.
Counter-counter: If the line does hold up, those things will make this offense one, if not exactly to be feared, to have its efficiency unquestionably respected. Though it will depend on that line holding up.

3. Brandon Cox and the season of disrespect. How startling it's been to see the same quarterback who as a sophomore walked into the overflowing cauldron of noise and hatred that is a 6:47 p.m. kickoff in Baton Rouge, faced fourth-and-goal from the 5 with under five minutes to play, and calmly flipped the ball into the back of the end zone to give his team the lead suddenly told he would not be fit to quarterback at Troy, or Rice, or Lousiana-Monroe. That if Auburn had the sophomores currently quarterbacking at Ball State, SMU, and Arkansas St., they would be better off.

To take Jay Coulter's highly appropriate history lesson one small step further, Auburn has started four other senior quarterbacks in the previous 15 years. Three of them won the SEC West and the other went undefeated while on probation. And now the fifth has every drop of motivation and karma behind him he could ask for. As they were when Campbell got (essentially) booed in the opening game of 2004, the redemption stories are already writing themselves.

Counter: Who's to say he wasn't permanently broken last year? MG isn't the sort of disease that just magically disappears from the body like Magic Johnson's HIV.
Counter-counter: I'm taking his word and his coaches' word that he is 100 percent. If he is not ... well, yes, that will cause problems.

2. Tommy Tuberville, LSU, and Nick Saban. I have precisely zero doubt that after 2004, any coach in the SEC takes public perception more seriously than Tubby does. In fact, you will never convince me he wasn't already invested heavily--and delighted in--his team's clippings in the summer of 2003. That year he was able to blame the overflow of hype for his team's demise. Then the very next year he could blame the lack of hype for his team's vicious snub. It seems unlikely, to me, that Tubby will ever be happy with the amount of goodwill his team receives in the preseason, but that's how it goes for a coach whose teams have been floundering as the favorite and deadly as the underdog for nearly a decade; there will always be too much attention or too little.

But this off-season is a new animal all together. One one side there is the actual business of expectations, and by this point any public figure claiming that LSU will somehow drop the division title is a lone voice crying in the wilderness, taken as seriously as the bum on the park bench babbling madness. In the coaching staff appraisal above I linked to an outstanding RBR post from Outside the Sidelines that goes into great detail on the hidden problems and obstacles LSU faces this season. But for all his quibbling about the tongue-baths lavished on the Tigers recently, OTS still rankes them fourth in the nation and picks them for the SEC title. Brian of MGoBlog has twice now made strong arguments on behalf of an Arkansas team that I happen to agree is being written off far too quickly (just to warn you, he's also predicting an Auburn crash-and-burn). But there, again, sits LSU at No. 3 and as Brian's de facto SEC champ. Even experts (and I mean that as sincerely as I can ... OTS and Brian know far, far more about this sport than the likes of, say, Dennis Dodd) who don't think LSU's that good still think they're better than anyone else in the SEC; even those that think other SEC teams are very good don't think they're as good as LSU. That his team has gone (again) 33-5 in three years and now isn't even considered a threat surely, surely has Tubby griding his teeth in his sleep ... and just as surely has him stoking the fires of his players at every possible opportunity.

But methinks the LSU hubbub merely motivates Tubby. The Saban hubbub likely enrages him. A team that he has beaten five consecutive times, often in brutal fashion, now coached by an opponent he fought to a stalemate at the barest minimum (and once utterly horse-whipped with a team that didn't even win the division) ... and this, and this, and this is already the result.

This, almost certainly, is the most disrespected, overlooked, and just plain infuriated Tommy Tuberville has ever been. This is a coach who made public that he felt slighted on behalf of his quarterback not being named pre-season third-team All-SEC. That is a much, much smaller issue than the media storm enveloping 'Bama and LSU at the moment. And I suspect that Tubby, at this moment, would do nearly anything imaginable to crush the two of them and I suspect he is, at this moment, doing every single thing he knows to do to make that happen. No, he hasn't made too much noise about to the media. But I suspect still he is angry, he is wounded, and he is driven.
And when that has been the case for Tubby--see that horse-whipping I mentioned earlier, coming off the back of back-to-back defeats and LSU being made a heavy favorite on the road--he is not one to lose.

Counter: Motivation doesn't matter if, oh, Cox isn't healthy or Byrum wets his pants or the receivers can't get open in an empty meadow.
Counter-counter: Auburn's had problems before. As I've pointed out previously (at the tail end of that post), they're still 7-1 in three seasons as an underdog or three-point favorite or less, and the "1" was the John Vaughn catastrophe. That is what happens when Tubby and his team are focused and prepared, and they will be focused and prepared often this season.

1.A defense that will devour everything in its path. It's not just Blackmon and Groves. Pat Sims has allegedly been an unholy terror in camp, and he's the only one of the four up front that didn't start last year. Blackmon is flanked by one returning starter who's as steady as they come in Merrill Johnson (when healthy, admittedly) and another talented enough to crack the rotation as a true freshman in Craig Stevens. In the secondary, corner Jerraud Powers and safety Zac Etheridge have been two of Auburn's best players in practice, and neither one is SEC All-Freshman and appropriately-named Aairon Savage or seen-it-all veterans Jonathan Wilhite or Eric Brock. Or, hey, Patrick Lee ...

The point being: find a weak spot. Please. Throw, and Groves and Sen'Derrick Marks are on their way with Savage, Powers, and Wilhite out there waiting. Run the middle, and Thompson and Sims are happy to collapse the middle and expose Blackmon's terrible and merciless wrath. Run on the ends and ... well, best of luck moving Marks (6-1, 291) out of the way. My sole recommendation would be to run right at Groves and whichever of the less-terrifying linebackers is behind him, and pray you make the edge before Blackmon arrives. That's all I've got to offer.

But don't take my word for it. Phillip Marshall's been around Auburn for a long time and isn't prone to hyperbole. Hell, he's the sort who'd be perfectly happy with 9-4. And he says, completely straight-facedly, that this defense could be Auburn's best since 1988. Read it, opposing SEC offenses, and weep.

Counter: All you've talked about is the starting 11. There's no depth here and by the end of the season, this defense will be in shredded tatters just like they were vs. UGA last year.
Counter-counter: At linebacker, this is a vaild point--though Tubby's bunch once stuffed Spurrier and Grossman playing what I recall as a Pop Warner star, Andy Dick, and a J.C.Penney's mannequin at linebacker, so maybe it's not. Regardless, Tubby's recruited well enough that both the line and the secondary can stand a couple of blows. Again: Eric Brock and Patrick Lee may come off the bench. I happen to think that qualifies as good depth rather than the opposite.

This was relentlesly cheerleady, I know. The Cons post will be different. I do have genuine worries.

*HT to Bring on the Cats. Also, their TE is suspended. Good times.

Wednesday, August 22, 2007

Grazie

Auburn fans, I promise I tried to find the time to put up some new Tiger-related content these past couple of days. For God's sake, I haven't even linked to this yet (HT to Jay), and for no particular This is exactly the sort of thing that has, in the past, turned into a big deal reason I was happier than a geek in a tauntaun costume giving George Lucas a ride to read it.

Well, maybe not quite this happy.

Maybe tomorrow. (Also, check out the weekend posts if you missed them.) For now, I need to thank the bevy of entirely-too-kind people who helped turn my Arrested Development post into, well, something people have actually read, which is still a rather new and exciting development 'round these parts.

Anyways, many thanks for both the link and the kind words to Todd at RollBamaRoll (who sort of got this thing, pardon the pun, rolling), Kyle at Dawgsports, Orson at EDSBS, Brian at MGoBlog, Oops Pow Surprise at the Hawkeye Compulsion (people who have excellent taste in Blogger template choice, I have to say), the Clinton Administration, Rumors and Rants, Epic Carnival, ATVS, the many anonymous message boarders out there, and Beau Dure at SportScope, which was nice because that will totally impress my mother. Special shout-out also to Michael Litos at CAA Hoops for keeping a beautiful straight face. Apologies to anyone I've missed. You are all wonderful people.

Sunday, August 19, 2007

Arrested Development explains the SEC

A few quick notes up front:

1. This post is impossible without the indispensable Arrested Development fansite the-op.com. If you have any interest in the show at all, visit.

2. I’m using all sorts of factors in coming up with the comparisons to characters. Coaches, on-field stuff, gross stereotyping of fan bases, etc., all weighted completely arbitrarily on a case-by-case basis. Nothing here is worth getting worked up over.

3. I know it's long, but even if you aren't a fan of the show, do at least give the post a scan. Because you ought to be, and maybe something in here will be reason enough to at least Netflix Season 1. If you are a fan, either you'll really enjoy this or I've done a poor job with what should have been a solid gold idea.

On with the show.

INTRODUCTION



"Let me tell you something, sweetie. We may pick on each other, get into little scrapes, call each other names and occasionally steal from each other, but that’s because we are family. You have no right. You don’t get to do that." –Lucille Bluth

If you want to know why Arrested Development’s Bluth family is, in my exceedingly humble opinion, the closest, best, most fun metaphor out of all the potential TV / movie / other sports metaphors out there for the Southeastern Conference, it’s summed up in that quote.

When it comes to other SEC teams and their supporters, SEC fans are happy to do things like not vote for a meaningless thumbs-up out of pure spite, or make a convincing case another fan base is made up of a unique variety of Neanderthal, or declare that an opponent’s fans smell like a combination of fried batter and pork snout (and none of those examples even come from Auburn-Alabama). The SEC’s coaches, the alleged ambassadors of the program, do things like preface another school’s name with an f-bomb or, basically, call another team crap at the biggest media event of the year.


The Bluths, of course, are willing to defiantly throw their siblings' letters into the sea, blow up the family’s yacht, invent a new interpretation of a chicken’s clapping ability, and bleep immigrants with a mustache milk on her mustache milk mustache all in the name of needling other Bluths … and actually, that’s just one Bluth, G.O.B.

But as Lucille points out, the Bluths are (almost) always family first, everyone else second. They view screwing over their own as their exclusive right. And so it is with the SEC, where even the coaches with the fewest long-term ties to the league become its biggest cheerleaders overnight, where (almost) every SEC fan hopes and expects the conference to finish the bowl season undefeated, even it means an archrival having something to celebrate. Georgia might hate Florida enough to hire painters who had spent time in the Groundlings and a one-armed man to teach Florida an elaborate lesson about lesson-teaching, and still make a trip to Iraq to clear Florida’s name with the Buckeye lovers feds just a few episodes later.

Of course, the phrase “hire painters who had spent time in the Groundlings and a one-armed man to teach Florida an elaborate lesson about lesson-teaching” also speaks to the other reason the Bluths and the SEC are a match made in metaphorical heaven: just as there’s only one conference crazy enough to have 92,000 people attend an inter-squad scrimmage or with fans willing to file FOIAs and wade through thousand-page documents in an effort to uncover their own division-winning coach’s peccadilloes, so there’s only one former broadcast network show with nevernudes, hand-eating seals, Ben Stiller with his beard shaved into a “W,” and the immortal line “This close, they always look like landscape” as an explanation for why the U.S. Army is about to bomb Iraq. Only the Bluths are quite as wonderfully batsh*t as the SEC; only the SEC is quite as wonderfully batsh*t as the Bluths.

But which Bluth most helpfully represents each SEC football program? Here's the Roll Call:

1. ALABAMA = GEORGE



Once upon a time, they had everything. In George’s case, a lucrative real estate and frozen banana empire, millions of dollars, a cabin in the woods to take roller skate-wearing broads to. In Alabama’s case, national titles, the most successful coach the game had ever seen, Joe Namath taking roller skate-wearing broads to a cabin in the woods.

But eventually, time and law enforcement caught up with them. By the end of the DuBose era, ‘Bama was reduced to hiding in the football equivalent of the Aztec Tomb, waiting for punishment. (The NCAA dogs found Logan Young almost instantly.)

Since then the Tide have stewed in the NCAA’s jail, desperate to escape and reclaim their position at the head of the family. How desperate? ‘Bama hired a shirt-chasing Pac-10 passing guru to run the program; they might as well have been trying to escape house arrest via Japanese rocket-pack. I think there were probably more than a few ‘Bama fans driven nuts enough by ‘Bama’s failures to start asking their dolls if they had any solutions.

But another thing that George and the Tide have in common, unfortunately, is that any funerals held for them were probably a little premature, though Tide fans’ expectations of grabbing another SEC title this year are right up there with expecting a hot tub to successfully cook one’s boil-in-bag dinners.

Key quote: GEORGE: Hey, you’re not going to turn me in, are you? Because I had no idea there were sanctions against, uh, rogue boosters paying megabucks for overrated defensive tackles Iraq. You know, they-they sent me over there. They said, “Go build.” I-I... Do I look like a criminal mastermind to you? How do you get this ham open? I can... I can’t get this ham open.

2. AUBURN = MICHAEL



I know, I know, Homer McHomerson sees his own team as the star of the show. But is there a more perfect analogue anywhere for Auburn’s obsession-and-denial-of-obsession over usurping ‘Bama as the state’s best football team than Michael’s obsession-and-denial-of-obsession over usurping George at the head of the Bluth Company? If Alabama had a banana stand, rest assured Auburn would burn it down to make a point, even if there always is money in said banana stand. That Michael has to scream that he’s in charge even as George stews in prison reminds yours truly more of a little of Auburn’s recognition on the national scale vs. ‘Bama’s despite the, ya know, Thumb business.

But there’s more that that. At the risk of perhaps drawing the ire of my own readership, I think Auburn’s fans take a lot of pride in not only being Auburn, but in not being the fans of other teams; that we wouldn’t boo a national-title winning coach like LSU fans, that we’re not as arrogant and mouthy as Florida fans, that unlike Miss. St. and Ole Miss fans we cheer for a team that actually wins, we don’t have that coonskin cap hillbilly-thing the Tennessee fans have going on, and most importantly we’re not those damn delusional stuck-in-the-past rednecks on the other side of the state. Plus, we got screwed by the BCS.

This is how Michael sees himself, too. Not perfect, no. But at least he’s not the screw-ups his siblings or parents are.

Key quote: MICHAEL: I’m a saint, you know. I’m a living saint and I get absolutely nothing out of it. LINDSAY: Well, you get a false feeling of superiority. MICHAEL: Yeah, that is nice, but this time, it’s not enough. Why do I always have to be the one that has to set the good example for everyone?

Of course, Michael sort of has something of a point. So do Auburn fans, if you WARDAMNEAGLE ask me.

3. FLORIDA = LUCILLE



It was never a surprise when in the series finale, Lucille was shown to be the one pulling many of the Bluth Company’s strings all along. So it is in the SEC, where while ‘Bama and Auburn and the conference’s other old-school power-running teams were beating the crap out of each other, Spurrier’s Gators were simply busy owning the conference with the ruthlessness and confidence necessary to, say, kick off a drinking contest by saying their first one “didn’t count,” finish it with their opponent slumped over unconscious, and then head back to rehab just for the hell of it.

The Gators also share with Lucille a pure and undying love of scheme. It’s no wonder Spurrier took the league by storm; when the sort of coach who was more than willing to tell Tennessee Auburn said they’re a “stay-in-bed mom” while telling Auburn Tennessee planned to get them drunk in order to shake them down—again, basically all just for the hell of it—landed in a league that still considered the wishbone cutting-edge, you could have guessed what was coming. And now, naturally, the Gators have Meyer, who I’m guessing won a lot of those already-committed recruits by sitting down in their living room and beginning “I’m a horrible head coach.”

It’s also a well-known fact that Lucille and Gator fans would both enjoy sitting down to a meal of ONE HUNDRED COCKTAILS.

Key quote: BUSTER: Mom is becoming a little controlling. MICHAEL: What tipped you off? When she locked you on the balcony again? BUSTER: That was half my fault. I thought I saw a graham cracker out there. MICHAEL (to Florida Lucille): You baited the balcony? LUCILLE: Prove it.

4. TENNESSEE = LINDSAY



One of the show’s most inexplicable conceits (and funniest gags) is that stone-cold knockout Lindsay is so socially inept, wealth-conscious (you know what kind of cream appeals to Lindsay? The one made with with a million bleeping diamonds!), and desperate that she ended up marrying a sexually ambiguous nevernude and can’t wrangle so much as a one-night stand once freed to date around.

Likewise since their 1998 national title Tennessee has gathered the conference’s best collection of five-star recruits and pro prospects, but the closest they’ve come to winning a title / getting laid since was putting on a hot French maid outfit for the 2001 SEC championship … and then being forced to drag LSU’s garbage to the curb. Now Tennessee’s fallen so far they’re happy to cook up any 9-4 season with a smack of ham to it. If Tennessee gets so much of a whiff that BCS bowl representatives might be around, you can bet it’ll be going without a bra and hauling out the “SLUT” shirt.

And hey, speaking of the smack of ham, just as Phillip Fulmer is a caring and generous humanitarian in addition to being a giant porker, so Lindsay may at times be a selfish ditz, but she’s also more than willing to pole dance in the name of peace. (Note: the JCCW not responsible for mental damages caused by using the terms “Phillip Fulmer” and “pole dance” in the same sentence.)

Key quote (with sound!): LINDSAY: I’m going to see if I can squeak into the SEC title game with a 5-3 record get a wrench to strip my nuts … *Long pause* … I, uh, tried to be sexy. It just … got away from me.

5. GEORGIA = GEORGE MICHAEL



It’s not easy to come up with an SEC program innocent enough that it would claim to smoke marijuana like a cigarette for a family member or have to be told to take its place-keeping finger out of its math book (see above) or run a class president campaign with V.I.R.G.I.N. posters (“Voting in Righteous George Michael Is Noble”). Innocence has never been a strong point for either the Bluths or the SEC … it’s a good bet there are patsies trying to plant documents in the wrong NCAA file to get a player eligible right now.

But if there is a picture of innocence in SEC football (at least amongst those programs that take it seriously) it’s Georgia, the school where its Heisman winner could tear off a 50-yard touchdown run while scattering tacklers like bowling pins and celebrate by casually flipping the ball to the referee; where their born-again coach is occasionally depicted with a halo; where they *cough* qualify all their recruits academically. Even this summer’s spate of traffic and open-container incidents seem like so much harmless shenanigans compared to other schools’ problems, like the Dawgs are trying to prank call their father at work and end up calling him “Dad.” Those Stafford keg pics, while embarrassing, don’t mean anything more than, say, a dork showing off his best Star Wars moves on home video.

Just because Georgia isn’t one of the cool kids, though, don’t try picking them too low in the SEC East or stealing away their girlfriend to live on your yacht. You’ll get jacked.

Key quote: MAEBY: That Florida Steve sure knows how to please a lady. GEORGE MICHAEL: Good. I was hoping he would be gifted sexually. I guess it makes sense, you know, older guys expect certain things. MAEBY: They do? GEORGE MICHAEL: What a fun, sexy time for you.

6. ARKANSAS = G.O.B.



One of the two easiest calls on the board. If there’s any other program in the country more likely to pull the football equivalent of breaking out of prison by being stabbed by a white surpremacist or record a potential crossover hit duet with a puppet to break down racial barriers or know the Italian for brother while chasing the illicit “Hermano” on a Segway … I mean, why even ask? There’s not. Just as G.O.B. rises above to somehow become the hands-down craziest Bluth, so Houston Nutt and the Hogs have somehow become the no-questions-asked biggest hive of insanity in the insane SEC. I genuinely believe we’re only a few weeks away from Nutt being arrested for shoplifting at a local Gap after screaming "MICE!" and stuffing a bunch of shirts down Casey Dick’s pants.

What I want to see from here is—and bear in mind, all of these could totally happen—1. Darren McFadden pimp out a Segway to cruise Fayetteville in 2. Nutt respond to a bad non-call on the road with the chicken dance 3. The entire team take the field to the strains of “The Final Countdown.” (I would gladly give up two of my toes to see any one of these things happen, by the way.)

And oh, one more thing: don’t forget that Nutt is a magician capable of creating victories out of thin air, even if said victories smell like lighter fluid. You think the desertion of a bunch of losers from some high school is going to slow down a man with a $1 million dollar salary and a contract extension through 2012? COME ON!

Key quote: G.O.B (realizing that keeping Theresa Prewett around may not have been the best idea): I’ve made a huge mistake.

7. VANDERBILT = BUSTER



The other easiest call on the board. Like Buster and his back-stabbing family, Vandy isn’t really cut out for the cut-throat world of the SEC. They’re scholars; they enjoy scholarly pursuits. (Everybody together now: “Suddenly playing with yourself is a scholarly pursuit.” That was fun.) Sure, you could put Buster in charge of the family business or give Vandy a fourth-quarter lead, but it’s just going to lead to another crippling panic attack in the end.

Of course, just as it’s always fun to root for Buster to finally get the upper hand (pun very much intended, oh yes) on his siblings on the show, so Vandy is every SEC fan’s second-favorite team. It’s just so cute when the ‘Dores come back from handling some MAC team and crow about being put in something called “Hero Squad”; the seal is for marksmanship, and the gorilla for sand racing beating Temple.

However, now that Vandy actually has a coach who’s aware the blue on the map to victory isn’t, in fact, land, it is possible a few more SEC teams will find their tendons caught in Vandy’s claws.

Key quote: BUSTER: Just wanted to check in and make sure you’re aware that your ban on organized sports in this family has been violated. GEORGE: Ban on organized sports? BUSTER: You know, how you wouldn’t let me sign up for anything as a kid. GEORGE: Is that what you’ve been thinking all these years? No, no, look, you were... you were just a turd out there, you know? You couldn’t kick, and you couldn’t run, you know? You were just a turd. BUSTER: Prison has destroyed the way you talk. If that’s what it takes to impress these guys around here, then they are not your friends.

8. KENTUCKY = TOBIAS



The whole blue thing would be enough, really. That and that the program has been a Tobias-quality laughingstock for the overwhelming majority of its days, expecting the likes of Tim Couch and Hal Mumme to keep them aloft as they leap off the stairwell, then murmuring “We shan’t be telling your mother the NCAA about this, shan’t we?”

But past that, consider that both Kentucky football and Tobias live in a constant state of denial. Kentucky states over and over again it’s not just a basketball school, oh no, very interested in football. Definitely not only interested in basketball. Just as Tobias is totally devoted to making his marriage work and is a 100 percent heterosexual analrapist. Forgive me, but as Dave Attell so memorably put it, “If that school’s man’s into football straight, then I’m sober.”

Also, Tobias is renowned for his Wildcat-like agility.

Key quotes, three of them because Tobias is just that funny: 1. TOBIAS: I’ve been waiting for the universe to provide a path for me and... and I think it has. LINDSAY: You’re a basketball school gay. TOBIAS: No. No. No, I’m not... I’m not gay. No. Lindsay, how many times must we have this... No.

2. LINDSAY: Well, you know, maybe I would be more attracted to you if you were in better shape. You know, if were just more like basketball muscular and masculine. Does that make me shallow? TOBIAS: No. I was going to say the same thing to you.


You know what, rather than me transcribing just one part of it, just read this entire conversation between Michael and Tobias. You’ll thank me later.

9. LSU = UNCLE JACK



I had a harder time picking out a character for LSU than for any other team in the league. Stan Sitwell’s hair trouble reminds me of Miles Hat Monday, but he’s not really a Bluth … the Saban link and both fanbases’ quickness to anger mean that in some ways LSU is an Oscar-like doppelganger of ‘Bama/George, but LSU is way more successful than sad-sack Oscar … that they seem poised to take over the league, wear such unique, colorful uniforms, and have that cajun thing going for club sauce reminds me of Lucille II, but she’s too sympathetic a character for an Auburn fan to compare to LSU … so what to do?

I’m just going to make a little prediction here. Methinks Jimbo Fisher had an awful lot to do with LSU’s success—that while Saban and Miles have been out front hoarding the money and yelling “To the nuts!” it’s been Fisher carrying the team, a la Uncle Jack’s stooge Dragon. Uncle Jack can dream about hooking up with Lindsay without the aid of Dragon, just as LSU can dream about winning big without Fisher … but they’re not making that move without that moose.

Plus, the bring-on-USC bravado from both Miles and the LSU fans certainly has a certain similar overtone to Uncle Jack’s ill-fated weightlifting exploits. Let me just a pull a bit of transcript to illustrate what would happen if USC and LSU actually met on the football field: UNCLE JACK: Five pounds for every year of my life! … Release! (Loud cracking.) Too much! (Thud.)

Key quote: MICHAEL: You think you should be perched on the edge of the building like this? UNCLE JACK: Oh, Fisher’s Dragon’s got me. MICHAEL: Dragon’s at Florida St. in the bathroom.

10. SOUTH CAROLINA = MAEBY



If there’s any character on the show that can match Lucille for scheming and sass, it’s dropout-to-become-movie exec Maeby. You might even think of Maeby as a younger, miniature version of Lucille.

And at the behest of the SEC’s best coach for scheming and sass, South Carolina is quickly becoming a more trendy, miniature version of Spurrier’s Florida. Carolina’s records since joining the SEC have nearly all been the football version of crocodiles in spelling, meaning that just as the adults who are supposed to looking out for Maeby don’t realize she’s overseeing multi-million dollar movies from her bedroom, so I’m not sure the powers-that-be in the East (or many of their fans, in any case) realize that Carolina’s caught up to them.

Of course, as Maeby has her not-so-adult weak spots within her more adultish activities (I mean bribery, being bad at math in doing so, etc., you dirty-minded pervs), Carolina does have Blake Mitchell. We’ll see.

Key quote: MAEBY: How about I come with you? I mean, I could help you prepare. TOBIAS: Yes, well, it’s for the SEC East title a con man, which I don’t think you know anything about. And besides, don’t you have school? MAEBY: No. Um... today is “Help Your Dad Follow His Dream Day.” TOBIAS: Great. We can take the carpool lane.

11. OLE MISS = STEVE HOLT!



OK, so the malevolence of the Orgeron doesn’t exactly jibe with the happy-go-lucky affability of Steve Holt!, though I could totally see him walking up to the podium at a booster luncheon and introducing himself as Coach O! with those same trademarked Steve Holt! raised arms.

No, what makes Ole Miss so Steve Holt!-esque is the school and program’s dedication to (or at least, the image of dedication to) enjoying themselves even in the face of perpetual futility on the football field. No, Steve Holt! isn’t going to graduate any time soon and has G.O.B for a father, but that doesn’t keep him from joining the school play or running for a fourth term as student president or reminding us all there’s no “I” in win. No, barring the appearance of some long-lost Manning bastard child, Ole Miss isn’t about to win the SEC any time soon. But they’ve still got the co-eds, the Grove, John Grisham … winning isn’t everything at Ole Miss. It’s the sort of place and sort of football program Steve Holt! would totally attend and support … if he had the grades, anyway.

Key quote: TOBIAS: And Steven Holt? Where is Steven Holt? Steve Holt!: Steve Holt! TOBIAS: Yes. Get ready for the acting challenge of your sweet young life, fair lady, for you are my Beatrice! Steve Holt!: Beatrice!

12. MISSISSIPPI ST. = OSCAR



Tuscaloosa and Starkville are college cities only 81.4 miles apart in the same desolate semi-wastes of East Mississippi / West Alabama. Both employ a similar shade-of-dark-red-and-white color scheme. Mississippi St’s most famous (and arguably most successful) coach, Jackie Sherrill, played at Alabama. So the connections between these two schools run deep, and at a glance some observers (OK, Pac-10 observers flipping channels at 1 a.m. under the influence of Afternoon Deelite) might not even be able to tell them apart.

And yet just as George and Oscar are indistinguishable twin brothers (apart from Oscar’s beautiful, beautiful hair), and one brother has everything he could have possibly wanted (except for the hair) and the other has had, well, a lemon grove shot up by tanks and www.ImOscar.com, so the Tide have been the country’s most successful blah blah blah while State has made do with Rocky Felker and Omarr Conner.

The one positive for Oscar and State is that with expectations that low, any victory is a big one—and just as Oscar has a peculiar level of success with Lucille, so at least the Bulldogs have had those big, big victories over Florida. What’s unfortunate is that I’m sure many at ‘Bama (GEORGE: “I just want my brother to envy my money, but he’s got that hair! Why can’t I have hair and money and him nothing?”) would prefer that they had those victories to themselves (not that I blame them).

Key quote: OSCAR: Well, you make do what you have. I have lemons, I make lemonade. MICHAEL: That’s a very positive attitude. OSCAR: But I hate the lemonade business, I hate the grind. You have to grind so many bleeping lemons.

So that’s the post. The show said repeatedly, “You do right by your family.” I loved this show (I imagine that’s obvious by this point) and yeah, I love this conference—hope I did right by them.

I’ll follow-up with a supplemental post later this week with more characters from the show (Maggie Lizer, Stan Sitwell, Rita, etc.) and more characters from college football (Jim Delaney, Dennis Erickson, etc.). I reserve the right to stick with the ideas I’ve still got in the holster, but if you’ve got any suggestions, feel free to leave them in the comments.

Saturday, August 18, 2007

2007 A-U pre-view: Phil Steele and 2006 in the rearview

The first in a series previewing Auburn's 2007 season.

Auburn's 2006 campaign was the single most bizarro season this particular AU fan can remember. I'd like to think my running-gag recap of the Tigers' 2006 season from the Cheese Puff Previews encapsulates it in reasonable fashion: Auburn handed the eventual national champion and the SEC's second-best team the only two defeats either of them would suffer to a team that wasn't the other, went undefeated on the road including the record-tying fifth straight win over the Tide, and won the Cotton Bowl over a solid Big 12 team. Auburn also got absolutely crushed in a pair of home games against their second-tier rivals, letting a chance to contend for the SEC title slip away despite the kindest schedule the program has seen in years. After the season-opening drilling of Washington St. the injury-plagued Tigers also never looked like the offensively explosive team projected in the pre-season, relying more and more as the season progressed on a defense prone to game-changing plays, the SEC's best special teams, and good old-fashioned luck*.

So which view do you take: that putting together an 11-2 record and claiming the quality of wins Auburn did despite the injury issues and offensive struggles is another example, like 2000, of Tubby's teams overachieving? Or that the complete choke against the Hawgs and Dawgs with a national title shot in view (in both cases), deterioration of an offensive line that should have been one of the nation's best, and general inability to ever look like the exciting, dangerous team that finished 2005 despite the return of so much key personnel was another example, like 2003, of Tubby's hotly-hyped teams underachieving? It's like the arguments between those half-white half-black guys in that ridiculous Star Trek episode with those half-white half-black guys: you can see both sides of the argument at once at all times and it's well-nigh impossible to tell them apart no matter how hard you look at them.

Which one is beating Florida and which is losing to Georgia by 22?

Long-time readers (both of them) will remember that I was pretty decisively on the underachievement side of the fence at the end of the regular season. I have to admit the Cotton Bowl win (and greater distance from the embarrassment against Georgia) softened that stance substantially, as it became painfully obvious just how hobbled (i.e. quite) Cox and Kenny Irons were by that point. 11-2--particularly when the team's key offensive players were operating at about 37 percent for half the year and 3 of those 11 are Florida, LSU, and a Thumb--is still 11-2 is still 11-2 is still 11-2. Yes, it's still a season we're going to look back on with a fond glint in our eye 10 years from now.

But I don't buy the Tommy Tuberville's Best Coaching Job Ever evaluation, either. On the opposite side of the scale of 11-2 is this statistic from Phil Steele: Auburn was outgained in SEC play by an average of 33.4 yards a game. Average yards gained minus average yards allowed. Pretty simple, elegant statistic, and the only SEC teams with worse marks were Mississippi St., Kentucky, and Ole Miss.

Now, does that mark matter as much as the 6-2 record in SEC play? No. But it's not irrelevant, either. Auburn may have been 11-2, but it didn't exactly play like an 11-2 team, either. As I said in the post from last fall, Auburn should have been a better team in 2006 than they were in 2005, and the record--as important as it is, obviously--was the only measurable way Auburn got better. The injuries excuse some of that, but not an offensive line with that much experience and a first-round draft choice (and a second potential one in Dunlap) playing as poorly as they did, or the utter defensive collapse against Arkansas or Georgia, or the occasional coaching blunder like the late first-half ill-advised blitz that helpfully ushered 'Bama back into that game. A good coaching job? Most certainly. Tubby's best? Uh, no.**

The end result of Tubby's actual best coaching job.

The upshot of Auburn's struggles on the stat sheet, if not the scoreboard, are that certain commentators like Steele are expecting the pendulum to naturally swing back the other way, for the breaks that helped lift Auburn to a 5-0 record in single-possession games last season (6-0 if you include Florida, as you should) to break back in 2007. Thus does Steele rank Auburn all the way down at No. 41 and several prominent bloggers leave them out of their initial BlogPoll ballot entirely. Worse luck + tougher schedule + loss of critical special teams advantage = more losses, the equation goes.

And I would agree there's something to it. It's simply not feasible to think that Auburn could go 6-0 in close games again, though they may also not play nearly so many--the Tigers only played five in 2004 and 2005 combined (going 4-1, though two of those were the more-comfortable-than-they-looked W's over 'Bama and Va. Tech in 2004). If Auburn continues to run deficits in the battle of total yardage, yes, this year--without Bliss and V****n and Davis for a while, most notably--they will lose games they won in 2006.

But will they run those deficits? There are plenty of arguments that they won't, but my personal favorite is to look at a second, very different kind of pendulum. Here's Auburn's offense under Al Borges, in terms of points, rushing yards, and passing yards per game:

2004: 32.1 PPG, 183 RYPG, 237 PYPG
2005: 32.2 PPG, 194 RYPG, 216 PYPG
First two games of 2006: 37 PPG, 202 RYPG, 234 PYPG
Remainder of 2006: 22.5 PPG, 139 RYPG, 162 PYPG

In other words, the performance of the Tiger offense didn't just decline after the Week 3 LSU slugfest; it fell off a cliff, with points dropping by a third, rushing by more than a quarter, and passing around a fifth. I would argue that even with the understanding that Borges doesn't have the kind of overall personnel he had in 2004 or 2005, those first 27 games paint a truer picture of Auburn's future offense than the aberrant and injury-hampered final 11 games of 2006. All bets are off if Cox goes down, but otherwise, it's fair to expect the Auburn O to regress closer to (if not match) the mean established during Borges's crackerjack first two years. Combine that with a defense that by most accounts is poised to become a soul-destroying, hope-swallowing Death Machine, and that yardage deficit seems likely to become a yardage surplus in 2007.

So with one pendulum swinging one way and the other swinging, uh, the other, where does that leave Auburn? Although the official JCCW prediction will come later, my guess is right in the same zero-to-three loss range they've dwelled in since Borges arrived. Sorry, Phil.

*I know some fans will take extreme umbrage with the notion that any game won by their team was decided by something other than the brilliance of the athletes and coaches involved, but it's still unlikely Auburn gets the calls the way they did vs. both LSU and Florida (correct calls IMHO, mind you, but ones that could easily have gone the other way), the idiotic fake punt from Nebraska, the continued presence of Mike Shula on the Tide sideline, etc., all for a second straight year.

**BBC link just for the "Wait, the Brits have even heard of college football?" of it.

Chicken Little arrives as expected

I'd like to introduce you to someone.


This is Eltoro Freeman. In addition to possessing the five-and-a-half-star name "Eltoro Freeman," Eltoro is a four-star prospect according to both Rivals and Scout, is the No. 10 member of the B'ham News postseason Super Seniors, considers his Mom his hero, and has drawn comparisons YEAAAAAAHH to Tray Blackmon. Freeman is from Alexander City, AL and is a member of Auburn's 2008 recruiting class.

"Wait a minute," say the members of the peanut gallery. "Freeman signed as part of Auburn's 2007 class. And there are no four-star prospects from Alabama who have signed with Auburn in the 2008 class. Saban's stealing them all away!"

No, it's not, not that any Auburn fan should be surprised at being told that their sky is falling, particularly by Dawg fans and sh*t-stirrers like Finebaum. The hype tornado that swirls around Saban at all times and the cruelties of recruiting math ensure that Auburn fans can gird themselves against a number of "Dewey Defeats Truman!" declarations over the next several months.

"And today in sports: Saban owns Tuberville!"

It's true that the 2008 numbers don't look good for Tubby at the moment. But they were never going to look good. I've linked to this Saurian Sagacity post once already, but it seems worthwhile to look at it again since Auburn is in the precisely same situation that Mergz describes for the Gators (well, Auburn's recruits haven't been quite so highly rated. No a big difference, though.) With 30 recruits in last year's class and 25 the year before, there's simply no room for another large, highly-ranked class. The Tigers also have to be cautious; Tubby can't hand out early offers willy-nilly when there are so few to go around.

The biggest reason for AU fans to blithely ignore the Signing Day warnings of doom, though, is that those nine players who didn't qualify, like Freeman, aren't really members of the 2007 class. They aren't on the roster, they're not redshirtng, they're not at Auburn, they don't have scholarships ... the only connection to the Class of 2007 is their Letter of Intent. It would be much more accurate to assign them to the class of 2008, since first there's no guarantee they'll fulfill their commitment, and more importantly that's when they'll actually begin counting against the 85-scholly limit.

So while King Crimson may sign a heck of a class this year, it's not going to be anything close to the deathblow to Tubby I promise you'll hear it described as more and more as Signing Day approaches. Because Auburn's 2008 class is (very likely) going to have guys like Enrique Davis and Carlton Johnson in it even if they're not included in those end-all-be-all ranking.

Heck, it'll even have good players from Alabama in it. Just ask Eltoro Freeman.

UPDATE: Well, that's what he'll tell you, but he won't be one them. Check the comments for big fat D'OH! on my part.

Wednesday, August 15, 2007

Not necessary to add the insults here, we're just into injuries


I want a refund. Pre-season is supposed to be a magical time spent dreaming of sugar plums, SEC titles, undefeated seasons, Vandy ripping the Tide by 30 and Bobby Johnson and saying "This one's for the beat writers" afterwards ... you know, all the usual things.

But Auburn's pre-season to date has been less about players making breakthroughs on the practice field and more about, well, players just breaking, period. You could call it a MASH unit, but at this point, that's selling it short. It's more like a MASH ... brigade? MASH platoon? MASH battalion?

We'll go with that. The always handy Phillip Marshall handily catalogued Auburn's entire MASH battalion after Tuesday evening's practice, and it's not pretty. I'm not sighing and daydreaming about Tray Blackmon hitting Blake Mitchell so hard in Atlanta Dec. 1 Spurrier's visor falls off by itself anymore; I'm worried we're going to end up asking Michigan St. if we can borrow their concert pianist (he's like Rudy, sort of, but he plays piano and starts) to fill out the linebacking rotation.

But at least that worry can be put to good reasonable somewhat questionable use: namely, a list of which of Auburn's many injuries has me most worried. You could say it's a ranking of the ones I think are most important to the team, but it's really just about which has done the most harshing on my treasured preseason mellow. Your worry may vary.

Ranked from least to most worrying:

15. Steve Ensminger, shoulder. I'm sure his injury was painful and I'm glad he's already back at practice. But this also a shoulder injury to the de facto fifth-string quarterback who's already back at practice. I just seriously doubt that if the season goes off the rails, Tubby's going to look back and say, "The turning point was when Ensminger missed that week of practice ... it was all downhill from there."

14. Kyle Coulahan, broken finger. DT is a sore point right now, but not so much an injury that didn't keep a true freshman who only just switched from o-line to d-line out a few days is going to have me tossing and turning in my bed all night.

13. Montez Billings, hamstring. A could-go-at-any-time injury like a bad hammy is a problem for speed-merchant WRs like Billings, but Auburn has approximately 27 other highly-touted speed merchant WRs on the roster. Sucks for Billings, but I doubt he'll be missed too terribly much even if he doesn't recover fully.

12. Ryan Shoemaker, unknown. Even though Tubby his own self said Shoemaker got PWNED by Wes Byrum in punt practice yesterday, I'll still wager he ends up Auburn's starting punter when Byrum wins the PK job. Even so, if his injury isn't even serious enough for Marshall to name it, it's not that serious.

11. Jermarcus Ricks, hamstring. That it's a hamstring isn't good news (you'll hear that a lot on this list) and that's why he ranks above Coulahan, but he's back at work already, at least.

10. Gabe McKenzie, hamstring. Apparently not too bad a pull since he's practicing again, and Auburn has a flotilla of tight ends to deploy ... but this is the first guy on the list who's presence will be decisively missed if he's not available.

9. Bo Harris, shoulder. No, nowhere near as good a player at this point as McKenzie ... but AU's nowhere near as deep at linebacker as they are at tight end, and Harris was being talked up at the head of the non-Craig Stevens freshman LB corps.

8. Jason Bosley, knee. Just typing "Jason Bosley, knee" sent shudders down the ol' spine. Just a scare, supposedly, but it's not the type of scare to go away easily.

7. Merrill Johnson, knee. That Auburn's second-best linebacker continuing to struggle with what seems to be an unending and unnerving series of setbacks only ranks as my seventh biggest injury concern should tell you how miserable Auburn's injury bug has been the last two weeks.

6. Leon Hart, ankle. I'm confident the AU offensive line will hold together. But it just won't be possible if guys like Bosley and Hart (who will be counted on sooner rather than later even if he doesn't hold onto his starting guard position) aren't able to go. Tyronne Green also missed practice Wednesday, meaning Marshall ended up reporting this:
The No. 1 line in the first period of 11-on-11 included Ziemba and King Dunlap at tackles, Isom and Mike Berry at guards and Jason Bosley at center.
If you're keeping track, Tiger fans, that's one true freshman and two redshirt freshmen on the current healthy first-team line. I ... I, uh ... I think I'd better go lie down for a while. Don't feel so good all of a sudden.

5. Neil Caudle, separated shoulder. All right, now we're into the injuries that just make me go AW GOSH DAMN IT TO HELL every time I read about them. Caudle's injury isn't so bad on its own merits. So AU loses one of three virtually equal potential backups to a guy who's missed one hand's worth of snaps in two seasons. The problem is Kodi Burns. He's got prospects. He's bona fide. I for one want my four full years of Burns more than ever ... and an injured Caudle only brings that redshirt one step closer to incineration.

4. Tez Doolittle, torn Achilles. Out for year. Along with Gandy's forced retirement, the cruelest injury by far on the list. But as strong a year as Doolittle might have jad and as big a part as he'd have played in the rotation, he'd still have been a second-stringer behind Thompson and Pat Sims. The situation couldn't possibly blow any more than it does from Doolittle's standpoint, but the team's probably still a little better off than if it had been one of the starters. Like, say ...

3. Steve Gandy, concussions. Career over. The last line of defense between the Auburn linebacking corps and the Invasion of the Freshmen, and it's gone.

2. Carl Stewart, hamstring. The worst hamstring injury of the bunch, and of course it belongs to the most irreplaceabele guy on the offense in my oh-so-humble opinion other than Cox himself. Every metaphor you've ever heard regarding glue that holds a team together or a player who makes his team tick or does all the little things apply to Stewart. If that hammy flares up again in mid-season (as hammys are wont to do), a big chunk of what Auburn's offense will want to will go right to the locker room with him. The guy's a senior. I would be just fine, myself, with Stewart taking his sweet, sweet time in rehab and coming back ... oh, let's say about 30 minutes before the Kansas St. kickoff.

1. Tristan Davis, broken toe. Kickoffs have never been more important than they will be in 2007, both across the NCAA and at Auburn: Davis was the one special teams weapon Auburn had, the one trump card they could play when it comes to flipping field position, finding extra yards, grabbing or stopping momentum with a big special teams play. Byrum and Shoemaker may be satisfactory, but they will not be weapons. Unless Fannin is even better than his early reviews, Auburn's special teams are officially the team's biggest vulnerability until Davis returns ... and depending on how that toe heals, could continue to be even afterward.

p.s. I know Tubby seems unfazed by the injury list and maybe I'm exaggerating the severity here, but a) from the coaching standpoint, it's always better for the confidence of the replacements to hand them a lollipop and tell them they're just as good as the guys they're subbing for b) would we even be fans if we didn't worry excessively about these sorts of things? c) lists and rankings = fun.

Monday, August 13, 2007

OMFG

An odd and unfortunate confluence of work, life, and preparing for the rigors of coming Saturdays with a full dose of the Premiership last weekend has kept me away from the keyboard for a bit. New post hopefully tomorrow, maybe Wednesday.

In the meantime, there's this superbly-titled publication:



Hat tip to Justin.

Tuesday, August 07, 2007

The Works, Streamlined-style

So many links, so little time. So there's a little less, uh, pontificating in this edition of the Works.

Now starting at strongside linebacker for Auburn, that kid from that YouTube video that's been posted a dozen different places. Or perhaps someone slightly, slightly older. Track 'Em Tigers (full Tubby transcript!) and Phillip Marshall's essential al.com blog (Pat Sims is going to rock!) have had Auburn's first weeks of practice covered like so many Sunday morning casseroles. (See, church lunches are called "covered-dish," right, so ... nevermind.) The biggest news has been that junior LB Steve Gandy's suffered a fourth concussion and his career is over. Obviously it's a terrible way for Gandy's time as a Tiger to end, but for Auburn's linebacking corps the more pressing issue is this Marshall quote:
Patrick Trahan, who left spring as a starter, is academically ineligible ... As of today, the starters are junior Merrill Johnson on the weak side, sophomore Tray Blackmon in the middle and redshirt freshman Craig Stevens on the strong side. Junior Courtney Harden is the backup on the weak side, junior Chris Evans in the middle and true freshman Bo Harris on the strong side ... True freshmen Josh Bynes and Adam Herring also could still get into the mix.
If Auburn has a non-suspended Blackmon and a healthy Johnson (and yes, I'd like to super-size that IF for 99 cents), you could line up C. Montgomery Burns beside them and have a quality unit. Stevens worked his way into the rotation as a true frosh last year before getting hurt, so you know both that he's got skillz and that the current crop of true frosh could be capable of contributing. Still: when half of your top eight linebackers are freshmen, yes, your depth could be better.

Coach, can you at least give him a coupon book or something? Dueling Cole Bennett articles this week from Marshall and the Montgomery Advertiser. I'm probably supposed to be troubled by Bennett's admission to the Advertiser that "it would be a lot better" if someone could cut him a check once in a while, but I just admire his honesty. Also, I admire him being 6-4, 255, and good at football.

ESPN hates you. I mean, it doesn't even like to look at you, it can't stand you so much. This write-up is dated June 28, so maybe I got the news then, took a Forget-Me-Now in horror, and only re-discovered it at CFR this week rather than saw it for the first time. It would be a reasonable response to learning that the move of Ron Franklin to ABC means he's not going to broadcast any SEC games this year. None. ABC's regional coverage is Big 10, 12, Pac-10, and ACC only. The closest Ron could get would be something like the UGA-Ga Tech or UF-FSU games. Instead, viewers watching SEC games in ESPN or ESPN2's prime-time will get more Mike Patrick (sigh) or the wondrous Mark Jones-Bob Davie pairing (sigh sigh). The guy with the beautiful Mississippi drawl, of course, will be off broadcasting Missouri-Nebraska. SighSighSighSighSiiiiiiiigh.

I haven't spent 80 bucks on a pair of shoes since 7th grade ... but, I do have a paying job now. Courtesy of Collin Mickle at the OA-News, Nike's got some sweet, sweet Auburn-inspired Charles Barkley kicks coming in October.
Air Chucksters!

A gift that keeps on giving, much like the elastic in his waistband. Food-lovin' fool Kasas St. QB Josh Freeman might have finally passed his conditioning test, but making up the lost practice time won't be easy. And, oh, the best time to play a team whose quarterback is still playing catch-up from starting practice several days late? Week 1, natch.

Spambots posting on Florida blogs are under the command of Brandon Cox! First Ryan Ferguson, now Orson, who left Auburn out of his top 25 and when pressed for explanation said "We’re not sold on Brandon Cox at quarterback. At. All." It's like Norm MacDonald's bit about Germans and David Hasselhoff, but it's Florida bloggers and Cox, and instead of love it's "slag off for no apparent reason."

Remember: 30 last year, 'k? Be sure to remember this Saurian Sagacity post when Auburn signs, like, eight dudes and nosedives in the recruiting rankings next year. Different school, same principle.

If I owned bagpipes and could play them, I would play them for you. The best of wishes to both Gandy and Tyrone Prothro, two careers ended long before their time.